Devnet Distro Roundup

I’ve been reading Yet Another Linux Blog for some time now as the writer (’Devnet’) has been submitting various distributions of Linux to a test. He’s used his wife (who has no Linux experience) as a judge to find out which distribution is the best distribution for a brand-new user to work with.

Devnet had his wife try out the following distributions (from having to install them to having to remove them - the whole experience):

I won’t mention how each of them performed individually except to say that there were two very big surprises. When Devnet tested Ubuntu it was found to be rather difficult for a newcomer to start off with. This generated a lot of (undeserved) negative feedback toward the project and the people involved from a rather excited Ubuntu community.

And the huge surprise was the success of the little-known PCLinuxOS. I’d never used it until it appeared in this project and was found to be the most new-user- friendly Linux distro. Granted, PCLinuxOS will not meet the needs of every Linux user - but that wasn’t the point of the experiment. According to Mrs. Devnet: “I need to do simple AND it’s easy on the eyes. It serves my purpose, bottom line.”

A big thanks from Distro Jockey to Yet Another Linux Blog for running this test. Linux is steadily approaching desktop-readiness for the real world - this will help the Linux community to know exactly what needs to be worked on to get us all the way.

Leave a Reply »»

8 Responses to “Devnet Distro Roundup” »»

  1. Comment by James M Wimmer
    05/09/05 at 4:25 pm

    Ubuntu only gets a 4 out of 10? That is just crazy! Ubuntu is one of the best distros I’ve ever used… I would have at least given it a 7 out of 10. I agree that the installation is a problem that I personally think needs a facelift, but other then that I love Ubuntu.

  2. Comment by Ryen
    05/11/05 at 10:31 am

    The experiment is really great. I could see their effort.

    Thanks Danger. Every time I come to you, I find really good info.

    By the way, is your trackback working? I even can’t find the trackback ping url. Or am I missing something?

  3. Comment by Danger
    05/12/05 at 10:17 am

    James: The guy running the test caught a lot of flack for reviewing Ubuntu so low. Even though I don’t run it after testing it for a bit I too believe it’s a great OS. The problem is that Devnet didn’t test the potential of a distro, he didn’t test what it stands for or how far it’s come - he simply tested whether a total Linux newb could use it.

    In this case, a Ubuntu failed for a Linux newb. I do believe, however, that for someone who wants more updated packages and a greater supply of them that PSLinuxOS will not be as good as Ubuntu.

  4. Comment by Ryen
    05/13/05 at 9:27 am

    Today I installed PClinuxOS. Seems good except one bug that is
    critical for me. It’s a font installation problem: say if there is
    already a font named ‘vera’ and if I install a font which has the same name
    (this does happen when we install a Windows font), X server dies.

    I figured out this after more than 1 hour of struggling :-(

  5. Comment by Ryen
    05/13/05 at 11:15 pm

    Additionaly I googled and found same situation but no clear solution yet.
    If you want to skim, the link is,
    PC Linux Online

    Workaround is a bit tedious:
    - login as a user
    - copy or link a font to ~/.fonts
    - log off
    - log on again. If you can’t log in, then delete the font from ~/.fonts
    - log in again. Copy or link another font and do the same thing. log
    off, log on.

    In that way I could install , some of windows fonts.

    Because I didn’t try all the fonts, I can’t tell which font cause problem.

    But definitely the truetype font that has extension .ttc (some Krean
    font have .ttc extension) cause KDE die.

    According to the above link forum, “Times New Roman” windows font may
    cause problems because its font name is “time”, which PClinuxOS
    provided in the box.

    I was assigned to a time consuming job yesterday.

  6. Comment by devnet
    05/18/05 at 5:01 pm

    Thanks everyone for your positive input on my little experiment. FYI, the conclusion will happen this weekend and from there we’ll look at doing an interview w/ the developer (lead) for the distro. Thanks again for your kind words.

    Devnet

  7. Comment by thebigfatgeek
    07/02/05 at 2:18 pm

    I have tried/used and installed at least 30 Linux distro’s over the last year, and normally ghost my desktop back to XP within a week and try another one. I came across PCLinuxOS on Wednesday, installed it a couple of times (hardware issues) and haven’t felt yet like taking it off my disk yet, which is a new record >4 days!

    I love ubuntu (I am a South African), but have to say, PCLinuxOS is good, although resource hungry. I have a P4 3.2GHz, 1GB Ram machine, and it “feels” slow, and on my kid’s spare PIII 500MHz it sucks, whilst the same machine runs SimplyMEPIS 3.3 quite happily.

    I will be looking at it keenly over the next few days, and who knows, I may set an all time record

  8. Comment by Rian
    08/02/05 at 3:18 pm

    I tried out PCOSLinux and at first found it to be absolutely perfect. Apt-get worked great; the distro installed fine; it booted with no problems; it was very easy on the eyes; everything seemed to work fine! However, after doing an apt-get update using the new package repositories that the PCLinuxOS team posted to their website, all heck broke loose. First, X-windows kept crashing. Then my keyboard upon trying to log in would not work no matter what I did. So I couldn’t log in. Not sure what happened, but I gave up. A great distro but beware of doing and update/upgrade.